Blogs
English
You are here: Home / News / Blogs / Aquaponics Vs. RAS: Scientific Trial Reveals Optimal Trout Farming Strategy​

Aquaponics Vs. RAS: Scientific Trial Reveals Optimal Trout Farming Strategy​

Views: 0     Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2025-06-19      Origin: Site

Inquire

facebook sharing button
twitter sharing button
line sharing button
wechat sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
kakao sharing button
snapchat sharing button
telegram sharing button
sharethis sharing button
Aquaponics Vs. RAS: Scientific Trial Reveals Optimal Trout Farming Strategy​

How System Innovation Enhances Fish Quality & Operational Efficiency

When farmed trout face consumer complaints of "excessive muddy flavor," or when traditional Recirculating Aquaculture Systems (RAS) encounter purification bottlenecks – a landmark study by three Finnish institutions (University of Jyväskylä, JAMK University of Applied Sciences, Natural Resources Institute Finland) delivers a breakthrough solution: Integrated Aquaponics Systems demonstrate significantly superior trout growth performance, flesh purity, and system stability compared to conventional RAS.

Aquaponics System1


Groundbreaking Discovery: Eliminating Off-Flavor Origins

Through comparative analysis of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) growth in Aquaponics versus standalone RAS, the research quantifies core system impacts on flesh quality:

  • Geosmin (GSM) Reduction >33%: Aquaponics-raised trout exhibited significantly lower accumulation of geosmin (primary earthy-odor compound)

  • Elimination of Depuration Phase: Traditional RAS requires weeks of fasting to purge off-flavors; Aquaponics inherently suppresses odor-causing microbes (cyanobacteria/actinobacteria)

  • Sensory Validation: Blind tests confirmed aquaponic trout had "clean flavor profiles" versus RAS group’s "pronounced muddy off-flavors"

Scientific Mechanism: Root microbiomes of plants (Spinacia oleracea) in Aquaponics actively degrade off-flavor compounds like 2-Methylisoborneol (MIB), disrupting the odor transmission pathway at its source.

Dual Enhancement: Growth Efficiency & System Resilience

▍Trout Performance Metrics

Parameter Aquaponics System RAS System
Daily Weight Gain (DWG) ↑ Increased by 15% Baseline
Specific Growth Rate (SGR) Significantly Higher Lower
Feed Conversion Ratio (FCR) ↑ Optimized by 7% Unimproved

▍50% Accelerated Nitrification, Enhanced Stability

  • Ammonia Clearance: 11 days in Aquaponics (vs. 18 days in RAS)

  • Earlier Nitrate Peak: Day 9 in Aquaponics (vs. Day 14 in RAS) – peak concentrations: 81.67 mg/L vs. 80 mg/L

  • Reduced Water Quality Fluctuations: Plant roots stabilize microbial communities

Unexpected Benefits in Plant Production

Even with identical micronutrient supplementation (Fe, Cu, Mn, Zn, B):

  • 43% Higher Spinach Biomass: Total plant weight in Aquaponics exceeded hydroponic controls

  • Root Adsorption Effect: Spinach roots concentrated geosmin, functioning as natural biofilters

Commercial Implications: Why Aquaponics Leads the Future

  1. Quality Premium: Solves RAS off-flavor constraints, unlocking premium seafood markets

  2. Cost Efficiency: Reduces depuration-phase losses and shortens production cycles

  3. System Resilience: Multi-tiered biofiltration mitigates water quality risks

  4. Circular Economy: Creates value chain: Fish waste → Plant fertilizer → Water purification → Fish health

"When harvesting both premium trout and leafy greens in one facility, we’re essentially redesigning industry value through biotechnology." – Lead Researcher

Ready to Upgrade Your Aquaculture Operation?
We provide integrated Aquaponics solutions for commercial-scale farms, enabling:
✅ Retrofit Upgrades of Existing RAS Infrastructure
✅ Customized Fish-to-Plant Biomass Ratio Modeling
✅ Real-Time Off-Flavor Compound Monitoring


Quick Link

More Links

Product Category

Contact Us

Copyright © 2025 BGT Hydromet. All Rights Reserved.